Photographic First #10 – Hippolyte Bayard’s faked suicide

BayardsFakedSuicide

Figure 1 – ,” the world’s first faked photograph from the Wikicommons and in the public domain.

Todays blog fits in both with our series of photographic firsts and with the question of photographic fakes and manipulations.  Figure 1, Hippolyte Bayard, “Self-portrait as a drowned man, 1840,” is widely viewed as the first photographic fake.  Hippolyte Bayard (1801 – 1887) was a French photographer and direct competitor with Louis Daguerre. He invented his own unique direct positive process, and exhibited his work on 24 June 1839. He claimed to have been the first inventor of photography, predating both Daguerre and Fox Talbot.

However, little credit came Bayard’s way and in reaction to what he perceived to be a great injustice, he created the first staged photograph entitled, “Self Portrait as a Drowned Man, 1840.”   In the image, he pretends to have committed suicide.  On the back of the photograph Bayard wrote:

Figure 2 - Hippolyte Bayard Self Portrait, 1863, from the Wikicommons and in the public domain.
Figure 2 – Hippolyte Bayard Self Portrait, 1863, from the Wikicommons and in the public domain.

“The corpse which you see here is that of M. Bayard, inventor of the process that has just been shown to you. As far as I know this indefatigable experimenter has been occupied for about three years with his discovery. The Government which has been only too generous to Monsieur Daguerre, has said it can do nothing for Monsieur Bayard, and the poor wretch has drowned himself. Oh the vagaries of human life….! … He has been at the morgue for several days, and no-one has recognized or claimed him. Ladies and gentlemen, you’d better pass along for fear of offending your sense of smell, for as you can observe, the face and hands of the gentleman are beginning to decay.”

This announcement of Bayard’s untimely death in 1840 was premature, as illustrated by Figure 2, a second self-portrait taken twenty three years later in 1863. He went on to enjoy a highly successful career in photography and died in 1887 at age 86.

Photoshop as a dirty word

I thought that it would be interesting to explore further this issue of photo-manipulation.  Is it art or is it always a bad thing?  Recently someone complained to me about the degree of manipulation being put it some digital images  It’s always expressed today as “that was Photoshopped” or even merely “shopped.”  This means that Photoshop has joined the elite pantheon of brands that have become catch-all verbs, like Xerox and Bing.  Indeed, and I love this, the process of so much recognition that a word becomes universal has been referred to as “genericide.”

It is all, obviously a matter of context.  In art anything goes (as long as it isn’t hateful, perverse, or exploitative).  And I stick with those exceptions.  But beyond these, in art image manipulation software is a tool that furthers the artist’s ability to express him- or herself.  It is like any new artistic medium.Beyond that, we move into the high fidelity zones of science and press photography.  In these two areas, the absolute truth is required – no image manipulation allowed.

In science, this gets really interesting.  In the analogue days, films and papers were intrinsically nonlinear.  Indeed, they were logarithmic in response.  As a result, while dodging and burning were strictly forbidden, the very act of choosing a paper contrast grade was inherently manipulation, even though it was considered acceptable then.    Today, you are expected to be linear.  You can histogram equalize as long as the settings are maintained for experimental and control images and as long as you do not clip detail into the blacks.  It’s a bit complicated and made even more so by imaging systems that automatically set all sorts of experimental parameters.

In press photography the big issue is that what you are photographing is real.  That is that you haven’t removed details or added any.  Photo-montage is a strictly forbidden.  However, aesthetically tweaking the image, as we would an image in fine art photography, is allowed.

The problem with press photography is that it’s a close kissin’ cousin of advertising photography – and those guys will alter everything.  The goal of advertising is to sell brand or politics, and they do it with a vengeance.  And since the goal of press photography is to sell newspaper or television or other media, things start to get seriously blurred.  However, it remains the responsibility of a free press to be truthful and to report.  This is more and more forgotten today – still it remains paramount.

I’d like in the next few blogs to consider some of the classic examples of manipulated photography.  At a superficial level it may appear that there is considerable grey involved in the deduction of whether a given example is good or bad in an ethical sense.  I believe, however, that on careful consideration the absolute criteria remain.  You don’t need Bertrand Russell, only your mother.  Is it meant to fool or deceive?  Is it meant to manipulate?  Is it hateful, perverse, or meant to exploit?  I think that the ultimate criteria remain.  In art almost every manipulation is acceptable.  In science and press photography almost no manipulation is acceptable.  And as for advertising, I guess that we have to recognize it for what it is.  But do remember, especially when politics is involved that the stakes are very high, and by dashing off a supposedly funny or telling political image on the web, however manipulated, we ourselves become manipulated pawns in the process.

P-n junctions and the heart of the LED display

Figure 1 - schematic of the p-n junction of an LED.  Top shows distribution of electrons and holes in the two regions. Bottom shows the conductance and valence bands. From the Wikicommons by S-kei and in the public domain under creative common license.

Figure 1 – schematic of the p-n junction of an LED. Top shows distribution of electrons and holes in the two regions. Bottom shows the conductance and valence bands. From the Wikicommons by S-kei and in the public domain under creative common license.

We now have the background information about semiconductors that we need to start to talk about digital photography – about digital array displays and digital sensor arrays.  Let’s start with a discussion of LED (light emitting diode) displays.  If you sigh at this point and try to escape to elsewhere on the web, chances are that an LED display will still be staring you in the face.  If you instead try to escape by watching television, the chances are still very high that an LED display is staring you in the face.  So under the assumption that it’s worth knowing as much about your computer as it knows about you, let’s proceed.

In my last technical blog, I discussed p and n type semiconductors.  In and of themselves, they’re not too exciting.  However, the fun begins when we start to combine them.  Suppose we put a p type semiconductor right up against an n type semiconductor.  This is what is called a p-n junction.  This is also called a diode and is shown graphically in Figure 1, where we’ve even allowed for a small transition region.  The p region is shown in blue and the n region in green.  You’ll note that we’ve connected this to a battery.  The plus terminal to the p side and the negative terminal to the n side, as one might expect.  Once the battery is connected, the electrons start to flow towards the plus terminal (remember that opposites attract).  Remember also that electrons can flow.  Holes really only appear to flow because the electrons are flowing.  So there is a current in the semiconductor, with electrons flowing from the n region into the p region and on to the plus terminal of the battery.  Of course, electrons exit the negative terminal of the battery and enter the n side of the diode.  If you hooked the battery up backwards there would be no current.  A diode is unidirectional.

As an aside, in the center we see the symbol for a diode, with its big honking arrow showing the direction that current flows.  This is because back in the eighteenth century no less than Benjamin Franklin made the unlucky guess that the charge carrier was not the negative but the positive charge, and this view is perpetrated by convention in circuit theory today, even though everyone knows that it is wrong.

Figure 2 - Large size red, green, and blure LEDs the fundamental components of an LED display.   From the Wikicommons by PiccoloNamek  and in the public domain under creative common license.

Figure 2 – Large size red, green, and blure LEDs the fundamental components of an LED display. From the Wikicommons by PiccoloNamek and in the public domain under creative common license.

The key thing about the light emitting diode (LED) is that when the electrons enter the p region they recombine with and neutralize holes.  This represents as shown in the lower portion of the schematic a transition from the conductance band back to the valence band with the emission of light whose color depends on the transition energy.  Hence, electrical energy is converted to light at the junction.

In Figure 2, I show diodes of the three primary colors: red, green, and blue.  If you take a magnifying glass up to your LED display, you will see minute arrays of these red, green, and blue LEDs each of which is individually addressable, meaning the light intensity of each can be individually controlled so that whatever color you and intensity you desire is created by additive color.  That is basically, how an LED display works.

Photographic first #8 – Les Horribles Cernettes, the first photograph on the internet

There are something like 250 million photographs uploaded to Facebook each day, and, of course, Facebook is not the only repository for uploading images.  It is staggering!  But have you ever wondered when it all began?  What and when was the first photograph ever uploaded to the internet?

The answer to the what question is clear. It is a photograph of the parody pop-band, “Les Horrible Cernettes.”  The when is just a tad murky, but it was officially celebrate last July as having been July 10, 1992.  That’s twenty years ago, and those of us old enough to remember the internet of the 1990’s, remember it in all its DOS-based amber and green glory – just then blooming in color.

Last July was a fitting time to remember it, because on July 4, 2012, those of us with nerdy underpinnings rose early to hear lectures from the Central European Organization for Nuclear Research, CERN, announcing that events consistent with the fabled and long sought after Higgs Boson had been measured with strong statistical certainty by CERN’s large Hadron collider. (How’s that for scientific equivocation and qualification?) CERN played a pivotal role in the development of the internet as it sought to connect its particle physicists and their computers from around the globe.

An idea was born, as were Les Horribles Cernettes, a singing group comprised of female employees of CERN.  Their first great hit was “You never spend your nights with me.  You prefer your collider,” and expresses the painful and particular lament of the significant others of physicists everywhere.  And finally, here they are singing their tribute to the Professor Higgs and his boson as the finale to their farewell concert at the Hardronic Festival 2012, last July.

 

New view from Cassini

Figure 1 - Venus glimmering brightly through the rings of Saturn taken by the Cassini-Huygens satellite on November 10, 2012 from NASA and in the public domain.

Figure 1 – Venus glimmering brightly through the rings of Saturn taken by the Cassini-Huygens satellite on November 10, 2012 from NASA and in the public domain.

As we have discussed before, the ultimate in robotic eyes are the cameras on our deep space probes. Among the most remarkable is Cassini-Huygens a Flagship-class NASA-ESA-ASI robotic spacecraft.  It was launched in 1997 and arrived at Saturn in 2004 having in the meanwhile observed Jupiter and the heliosphere as well as tested Einstein’s theory of relativity.  Good stuff for a “mere” robot.

Cassini today continues to send back very remarkable images of Saturn.  So a visit to her photogallery at NASA is worthwhile and fun.  NASA recently released a wonderful image taken on November 10, 2012, which shows Venus glimmering brightly through Saturn’s marvelous rings.  These amazing robots continue to provide us with images better than anything we could ever image.  The distinction between science and art dims and we have only begun to scratch the face of the universe.  If these images exceed our wildest imaginings then these robotic eyes may truly be said to have extended the limits of our imaginations.

Rest in Peace, Elmo

Figure 1 - New York City during the Great Blizzard of 1888, showing the tangle of electrical wires taking the strain of the snow.  After the disaster of the storm New York City began the task of placing electrical utilities below ground.  From the Wikicommons and in the public domain.

Figure 1 – New York City during the Great Blizzard of 1888, showing the tangle of electrical wires taking the strain of the snow. After the disaster of the storm New York City began the task of placing electrical utilities below ground. From the Wikicommons and in the public domain.

The weather in New York City in early March of 1888 was unseasonably mild.  On March 12 heavy rain developed and then turned to snow.   The snow became heavy just after midnight and continued with fury for a day and a half.  There was a total of about 40 inches in New York and New Jersey, while Connecticut and Massachusetts received as much as 50 inches.  In New York City at the height of the storm winds gusted to forty miles per hour and snow drifts averaged 30 to 40 feet in New York and New England.

The Great Blizzard of 1888 was  the perfect formula for disaster as the City was a tangle of electrical, telegraph, and telephone wires.  The wires rapidly became covered in snow and were brought down by shear weight and ferocious winds.  People were electrocuted by falling wires and their bodies not found for weeks until the snow melted.

Figure 2 - My grim discovery (c) DE Wolf 2013

Figure 2 – My grim discovery (c) DE Wolf 2013

I remember a diorama of the storm at the American Museum of Natural History in NYC and my father recounting the story as if he had lived it.  Such were my memories and thoughts on Monday afternoon, as I walked along the Charles River Reserve beneath the Watertown, MA bridge.  Our own blizzard was reduced to memory now with almost all the snow melted and remnants of colossal drifts now yielded their own detritus.

12:45 PM EST was when I found him.  It was near the children’s playground on the north bank of the river about a mile east of the bridge.  I was glad that there were no children present to witness my grim discovery.  I saw him first lying face down in the flotsam of now wasted snowdrifts.  His fur was grimy but unmistakably red.  One eye was turned back in his head.  I turned him over to confirm his identity.  We await DNA verification, but it all seems sadly certain.  Rest in peace, little red friend.

Example of Post Markup and HTML

Headings

Header one

Header two

Header three

Header four

Header five
Header six

Blockquotes

Single line blockquote:

Stay hungry. Stay foolish.

Multi line blockquote with a cite reference:

People think focus means saying yes to the thing you’ve got to focus on. But that’s not what it means at all. It means saying no to the hundred other good ideas that there are. You have to pick carefully. I’m actually as proud of the things we haven’t done as the things I have done. Innovation is saying no to 1,000 things. Steve Jobs – Apple Worldwide Developers’ Conference, 1997

Tables

Employee Salary
John Saddington $1 Because that’s all Steve Job’ needed for a salary.
Tom McFarlin $100K For all the blogging he does.
Jared Erickson $100M Pictures are worth a thousand words, right? So Tom x 1,000.
Chris Ames $100B With hair like that?! Enough said…

Definition Lists

Definition List Title
Definition list division.
Startup
A startup company or startup is a company or temporary organization designed to search for a repeatable and scalable business model.
#dowork
Coined by Rob Dyrdek and his personal body guard Christopher “Big Black” Boykins, “Do Work” works as a self motivator, to motivating your friends.
Do It Live
I’ll let Bill O’Reilly will explain this one.

Unordered Lists (Nested)

  • List item one
    • List item one
      • List item one
      • List item two
      • List item three
      • List item four
    • List item two
    • List item three
    • List item four
  • List item two
  • List item three
  • List item four

Ordered List (Nested)

  1. List item one
    1. List item one
      1. List item one
      2. List item two
      3. List item three
      4. List item four
    2. List item two
    3. List item three
    4. List item four
  2. List item two
  3. List item three
  4. List item four

HTML Tags

These supported tags come from the WordPress.com code FAQ.

Address Tag

1 Infinite Loop
Cupertino, CA 95014
United States

Anchor Tag (aka. Link)

This is an example of a link.

Abbreviation Tag

The abbreviation srsly stands for “seriously”.

Acronym Tag (deprecated in HTML5)

The acronym ftw stands for “for the win”.

Big Tag (deprecated in HTML5)

These tests are a big deal, but this tag is no longer supported in HTML5.

Cite Tag

“Code is poetry.” —Automattic

Code Tag

You will learn later on in these tests that word-wrap: break-word; will be your best friend.

Delete Tag

This tag will let you strikeout text, but this tag is no longer supported in HTML5 (use the <strike> instead).

Emphasize Tag

The emphasize tag should italicize text.

Insert Tag

This tag should denote inserted text.

Keyboard Tag

This scarsly known tag emulates keyboard text, which is usually styled like the <code> tag.

Preformatted Tag

This tag styles large blocks of code.

.post-title {
	margin: 0 0 5px;
	font-weight: bold;
	font-size: 38px;
	line-height: 1.2;
	and here's a line of some really, really, really, really long text, just to see how the PRE tag handles it and to find out how it overflows;
}

Quote Tag

Developers, developers, developers… –Steve Ballmer

Strike Tag (deprecated in HTML5)

This tag shows strike-through text

Strong Tag

This tag shows bold text.

Subscript Tag

Getting our science styling on with H2O, which should push the “2” down.

Superscript Tag

Still sticking with science and Isaac Newton’s E = MC2, which should lift the 2 up.

Teletype Tag (deprecated in HTML5)

This rarely used tag emulates teletype text, which is usually styled like the <code> tag.

Variable Tag

This allows you to denote variables.

P and n type semiconductors – doping and stacking the odds in your favor

Figure 1 - Schematic of a semiconductor crystal at absolute zero where all of the electrons are bound up by holes.

Figure 1 – Schematic of a semiconductor crystal at absolute zero where all of the electrons are bound up by holes.  (c) DE Wolf 2013.

As we have seen, the fundamental silver halide chemistry of analogue photography depends upon the physics of semiconductors.  And yet, it was developed before anyone knew about semiconductors or even uttered the word.  Indeed, in those days they didn’t need to utter the word “analogue” in relation to photography, because there was no digital photography to contrast it with.  The same is true for watches.  In the “dinosaur ages,” when I was a lad, there were just watches not analogue watches and certainly not digital watches.  Indeed, the time is fast approaching when there may be no watches except during retro-fashion fads.

But, as I promised, semiconductors will explain a lot of the technical aspects of digital photography.  To get there we need to discuss one more aspect of semiconductor physics – qualitatively I promise.

At absolute zero the valence electrons have no excess kinetic energy and are all sitting in their valence bands.  This is shown in Figure 1.  All of the positively charged holes are paired up with negatively charged electrons – very boring.  Now as we heat up the semiconductor to room temperature, some of the thermal (heat) energy gets absorbed by the electrons and they can escape to the conduction band where they are free to move.

Figure 2 - Schematic of a semiconductor crystal at room temperature where some of the electrons have escaped the lattice and are in the conductance band.  There are functionally two types of charge carriers: the free electrons and the positive holes. (c) DE Wolf 2013.

Figure 2 – Schematic of a semiconductor crystal at room temperature where some of the electrons have escaped the lattice and are in the conductance band. There are functionally two types of charge carriers: the free electrons and the positive holes. (c) DE Wolf 2013.

Free to move means that if I attach a battery to two sides of the crystal current will flow.  Recognize, that as they flow in the current some electrons may recombine with holes.  But then new holes appear as new electrons escape and the net effect is that electrons move form the negative side of the battery to the positive side (remember that opposites attract).

But wait! Imagine that you are watching this process from  a distance.  Is it the electrons that are moving or is it the holes.  They both appear to be moving.  It’s like the sensation of being on a train and suddenly the platform appears to be moving.  Of course, we know that the electrons have escaped the crystal lattice, while the atoms (holes) have not.  But it does look like the holes are moving, and you can even calculate a speed for this motion.

The next question that we need to ask is whether there is a way of modifying the semiconductor crystal so that has more electrons or more holes?  Well, remember that whether a material is a conductor, a semiconductor, or an insulators depends on how tightly the valence electrons are bound to the positive atomic nuclei.  Remember also that the solid-state crystal acts as a unit not as a set of individual atoms.  The net-net of all of this is that if we add a small amount of a material that tends to donate electron the crystal will have more free electrons (in the conductance band).  If we add a small amount of a material that tends to bind up electrons (in the valence band) it will have more holes.  The materials added are called “doping agents.”  Semiconductors with excess negative charge (electrons) are called “n-type semiconductors.”  Semiconductors with excess positive charge (holes) are called p-type semiconductors.

The cool thing is that doping can be a very localized process, and as a result, you can build up some very complex semiconductors capable, for instance, of creating a computer and displaying your photographs on a light emitting diode display.  That will be the topic of our next technical blog.